| 1. |  Channel Awesome | 9,280,484 | The Cat in the Hat (Original Edit) - Nostalgia Critic | 26:41 |
| 2. | Peebs | 75,969 | Nostalgia Toys! | Cooking Pikachu in my EZ Bake Oven | 24:01 |
| 3. | SimplyUnlucky | 57,481 | *RARE* YuGiOh Pharaonic Guardian 2003 Double Blister Pack Opening & Review! Nostalgia is Real | 11:08 |
| 4. | CGRundertow | 54,594 | CGR Undertow - NOSTALGIA review for Nintendo DS | 4:07 |
| 5. | dragon1130 | 19,225 | Nostalgia critic Highlights - The best Speech against Meninists (Mad Max: Fury Road Review) | 1:22 |
| 6. |  Xataka | 17,306 | SNES Mini: Nintendo nos vuelve a ganar con la nostalgia | 3:55 |
| 7. | Nostalgia Wound | 15,476 | Wallace & Gromit: Curse of the Were-Rabbit (Xbox) Review - Nostalgia Wound | 5:13 |
| 8. | Chibi Reviews | 15,467 | Ultimate Gohan Has Returned.... So Much Nostalgia | 17:03 |
| 9. | Madlittlepixel | 9,755 | Milking Retro Nostalgia - Cotton 100% Nintendo Switch Review! | 8:20 |
| 10. |  SavageZweiPanda | 8,012 | Yu-Gi-Oh! Arc-V Anime Episode 106 遊戯王 アーク・ファイブ GX NOSTALGIA RUSH Review | 13:34 |
| 11. |  Cosplay Chris | 5,340 | Does "Ghostbusters: Afterlife" Have Too Much Nostalgia?- Movie Review | 10:13 |
| 12. | Phil Of Glimmer | 2,543 | Asterix Mega Madness - Nostalgia Review ...Two-Player With My Brother! | 11:48 |
| 13. | GameTrailers Archive | 1,903 | Nostalgia - GT Review | 6:19 |
| 14. |  Beyond Reality [CD10] | 1,646 | Nostalgia Critic - HEEEEEEELP! (Batman and Robin review) | 0:03 |
| 15. |  SBT GAMES | 870 | BLIZZARD ARCADE COLLECTION: NOSTALGIA DE ALTA QUALIDADE - REVIEW | RG #18 | 2:32 |
| 16. | JayBee & Milly | 816 | Scooby-Doo, Where Are You! In: Mystery Mask Mix-Up Review | smASH or Pass? (Nostalgia) | 47:41 |
| 17. |  Blaze The Movie Fan | 564 | Video Thoughts: Nostalgia Critic's Home Alone 2: Lost In New York Movie Review | 21:02 |
| 18. | SwitchScheme | 174 | 1 Minute Review - Risen - Nostalgia At a Cost! | 1:00 |
| 19. | The Toy Temple | 145 | Nifty Nostalgia: Star Wars Power of the Force Luke Skywalker Action Figure Review | 1:57 |
| 20. |  Reystation | 126 | Nostalgia Tapi Bukan Zamannya - Activison Classic (PS1) - Review Game Jadul (Retro) | 4:02 |
| 21. | Murray React and Gaming | 119 | The Weirdest Stephen King Movie of Toilet Aliens - Nostalgia Critic Dreamcatcher Review Reaction | 30:06 |
| 22. | vypermajik | 95 | The Video Kid (80s Edition) - Xbox One Review - 80's pop nostalgia!! | 3:43 |
| 23. |  CFN Gaming | 93 | Nostalgia like Never Before - Neighborhorde Review | 4:22 |
| 24. | Godzilla McCollum 2000 | 59 | I dare the Nostalgia Critic to review the 1st 4 Friday The 13th movies episode 84 | 7:33 |
| 25. | Dicebag Games | 21 | The Smell of Nostalgia (Pokemon TCG Champion's Path Pack Review) | 11:04 |
| 26. | Teddie Teddie | 2 | Nostalgia Critics Transformers reviews (1-3) | 13:02 |
