GAME CRITIQUE IS DEAD: Why Reviewers SHOULD Be Skilled Players | The Definitive Discussion

Channel:

The Electric Underground

Subscribers:

31,200

Published on May 11, 2023 6:45:10 PM ● Video Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7Q8GAMdFwA

Game:

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom (2023)

Category:

Review

Duration: 2:33:54

11,766 views

493

GAME CRITIQUE IS DEAD: Why Reviewers SHOULD Be Skilled Players | The Definitive Discussion. Today is a very special video where @boghogSTG and I discuss the current (and awful) state of video game reviews and critique. This isn't just a bunch of empty complaining, however (at least I hope so). Instead we discuss the nature of what is good critique, what is the role of the critic vs reviewer, what forces influence critics and reviewers, both conscious and unconscious. We also make our strongest case for why video game reviewers SHOULD be skilled players, why this is an important value a critic should strive for, and how being a skilled player not only improves reviews, but also is an important asset for game developers as well. We also get into the topic of access journalism that we see IGN and the major game publishers engaging in (such as IGN infamously "forgetting" to review Cyber Punk 2077) and how the video game review space has more in common with the Yakuza than it does open artistic discourse. Sphere Hunter may be invited to Capcom events, but she's not at the IGN level of access to be allowed to review the game before the release date. Imagine all the NDA's that level of access would involve.
Talking about IGN, eurogamer, Polygon, Kotaku, and Gamespot is one thing, but we also get into what is the role of the youtuber in this equation and how even if the youtuber is not direclty being contacted by game publishers, he is still being indirectly shaped by the marketing of AAA games and their vocal fanbases. As a result, we see a cyclical trend of hype marketing around releases like Resident Evil 4 Remake, The Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild (and soon to be Tears of the Kingdom), and Bayonetta 3, where all the reviews are going to fall in line with the marketing. And if you are more critical of these games during their release window, prepare to be hit by the hype train, which is not going to be a fun expereince. As a result, I think we've seen a shift in the youtubing meta away from the over the top reviews that we saw in the Angry Video Game Nerd era of gaming youtube. Instead, we are now in the fluf**** era, where youtubers take games that are already hyped and highly anticipated, and then just dial the hype levels up even higher (as we see on Maxamillion Dood's channel). So now all average games are *amazing* and all good games are modern masterpieces.

Awesome thumbnail created by @boghogSTG

Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/electricunderground
[$2 tier = Monthly Game Review Vote, Name in Credits, Exclusive Monthly Podcast]
[$5 tier = Double Monthly Game Review Vote, By Name Shout-out, Name in Credits, Exclusive Monthly Podcast]
Website: https://theelectricundergr.wixsite.com/the-electric-undergr
My Discord Stream Server:
https://discord.gg/EeqSDryGea
Electric Reddit:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ElectricUnderground/
👕Official Shirt!👕
https://amzn.to/2XghV9J
Twitch:
https://www.twitch.tv/the_electric_underground
STG Revision 2020 Discord:
https://discord.gg/snRueeH

00:00:00 Bog Escapes the Thumbnail Dungeon
00:02:30 Difference Between Critics and Reviewers
00:16:00 Corrupt IGN and Access Journalism
00:24:00 Are "Reviewers" Shills or Critics?
00:32:25 Reviews Use Childish Humor to Hide Ignorance
00:39:12 If You Can't Play, You Can't Derive First Hand Insight
00:45:50 You Need Skill To Assess Difficulty Correctly
00:51:40 You Can't Understand Fundimental Design Without Playing
00:58:00 Critics Are NOT Marketers, They Need to be Capable of Independent Analysis
01:05:04 Your Hands Understand Faster Than Your Brain
01:13:06 You Can be an Expert and RELATABLE
1:16:10 - Devil's Advocate - #1 "There's too many games!"
1:20:12 - Devil's Advocate #2 - Toxicity
1:23:05 - Devil's Advocate #3 - Don't lose relatability
1:26:21 - Devil's Advocate #4 - How good is too good?
1:35:25 - Devil's Advocate #5 - Avoiding tunnel vision/genre conventions
1:43:20 - Avoiding peer pressure culture
[Why Gamedevs gotta get good]
1:48:00 - Gamedevs need to stay in touch
1:48:40 - How do you find the time?
1:50:40 - Why should you care about artistic merits?
1:54:28 - Take hardcore gaming to the normies
1:59:10 - The importance of intuition
2:07:20 - Staying in touch with your inner n00b
[A short segment about reviewers]
2:09:45 - Finding the vertical slice & completionism
[Devil's Advocate GAMEDEV VERSION]
2:19:00 - Devil's Advocate #1 - Avoiding becoming a slave of conventions
2:22:46 - Devil's Advocate #2 - Are all of us just coping from a lack of success?
2:24:26 - Devil's Advocate #3 - What to do if your tastes are too niche
[OUTRO]
2:30:25 - The end 😦

#IGN, #residentevil4remake, #tearsofthekingdom

Other Statistics